Agriculture Ruined the World

Add New Comment

Subscribe:  This Thread

Go to:  My Comments ·  Community Page

Sort thread by: Hot comments Best comments Newest first Oldest first

Viewing 3 Comments

• 
  • 
  • 
  

  • Permalink
  • Admin
  • • Remove Post
    • Block email
    • Block IP address

  Carl M 5 months ago 1 point

  Please login to rate.

  Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.

  I don't get this at all. He explains many of the ways in which agriculture has improved life on Earth for mankind. Then he poses the ENTIRELY IRRELEVANT QUESTION: How do you show that the lives of people 10,000 years ago got better when they abandoned hunting and gathering for farming?

  
  

  That's like asking "How do you show that the lives of (let's say) British soldiers during World War II got better when they fought the Germans?" Of course, they didn't. They suffered terribly, but that's not the point. It's the outcome that measures the success. And, most would argue that they did not suffer (and die) in vain, but to make the world a better place (or at least to preserve the values of Britain).

  
  

  Similarly, I don't think that anyone would claim that the lives of people 10,000 years ago got immediately better during the transition to a predominantly agricultural society. He gives evidence to show that their lives did not immediately improve, but I don't see that this is really the point. Certainly I find it rather absurd to call it Humanity's worst mistake.

  reply  edit  reblog  flag
  /people/f94a13a49486287a22f2096605da17a0/
• 
  • 
  • 
  

  • Permalink
  • Admin
  • • Remove Post
    • Block username
    • Block email
    • Block IP address

  Daniel Miessler 5 months ago 1 point

  Please login to rate.

  Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.

  I agree, Carl. I think it's specious at best. But it's though-provoking at least. I think it makes for good exercise to be able to articulate the problem with the argument.

  reply  edit  reblog  flag
  1 /people/danielrm26/ /people/danielrm26/following/ http://dmiessler.com/ danielrm26
• 
  • 
  • 
  

  • Permalink
  • Admin
  • • Remove Post
    • Block email
    • Block IP address

  Steven G. Harms 5 months ago 1 point

  Please login to rate.

  Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.

  This argument was made much more cogently in Guns, Germs, and Steel.

  reply  edit  reblog  flag
  http://www.stevengharms.com /people/b0806452a4ee1bf43075c74b5b16e374/

Add New Comment

Trackbacks

(Trackback URL)