Am I a Prescriptivist?

By Daniel Miessler on March 20th, 2008: Tagged as Language

And if I am, should I be?

A prescriptivist is essentially someone who adheres to and attempts to enforce language rules as they are today. This is in contrast to a descriptivist, who evidently cares more about how language is used rather than how it should be used.

Those are very course definitions, but I think it captures the spirit.

So I think that this scale, like most, lends itself well to a balance. This is to say that you shouldn’t be too far on either side. That being said, I think my tendency is toward prescriptivism. I don’t mind that as long as I keep in mind that language is in a constant state of flux.

Thoughts?

  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • HackerNews
  • StumbleUpon
  • DZone
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • del.icio.us
  • FriendFeed
  • Posterous
  • RSS
  • email
  

Comments

  • anonym

    You misspelled coarse. I'm betting it's the results of a somewhat shortsighted and prescriptivist spellchecker. It could also be argued that " it captures the spirit.", should be " they capture the spirit.".


    Cheers!

  • I think it depends on the context. If a black person says "aks", I don't have a problem with that in the context of day-to-day speech. If I see it in a professional oration, it makes me cringe.
    I try to speek clearly in my day-to-day speech, but when it comes to "Mike, Michelle, and I" I only use that when giving speeches at work or school because I think the grammarians are wrong on that, but they do dictate the professional rules.

  • I'm probably the same: somewhere in the middle, but leaning more towards being a prescriptivist. Knowing how language is currently used is important, but current use that is just ignorant and wrong is hurting our language. I don't see a problem with adding a verb like "google" to the dictionary or many other recent changes and additions, but common misuse of lie and lay for example is just wrong.

blog comments powered by Disqus

 

twitter_icon

Sample Original Content


Information Security

Tutorials and Primers

Culture & Society

Technology & Science

Politics

Philosophy & Religion

Miscellaneous

Tools & Projects


Blog Archives